top of page

Direct Mail vs Email Marketing

As a business operating in today’s digital age, you have a spectrum of marketing channels at your disposal. Two strong contenders, direct mail vs email marketing, come to the scene with distinct strengths and drawbacks. But which one to choose? 

As leaders in providing various printing services, we aim to simplify your decision-making process. We will equip you with the necessary knowledge about these marketing forms to help you decide which suits your goals.

Direct Mail vs Email Marketing
Source: / Photo Contributor: Andrey_Popov

Direct Mail vs Email Marketing

Marketing strategies have significantly evolved throughout the years. Direct mail and email marketing stand out as two prominent and practical methods for planning effective marketing campaigns and reaching a broad audience.

They aim to engage recipients, drive conversions, and contribute to business growth. Yet, both cater to different audiences and serve distinct purposes. But what is the difference between direct mail and email marketing? 

Understanding their characteristics and differences is crucial for effective customer acquisition and choosing the most appropriate method for your brand. Is direct mail more effective than email marketing? Let’s get into it and find out the direct mail vs email marketing pros and cons!

Definition and purpose 

Direct mail marketing

Direct mail is the act of sending physical marketing materials to the recipient’s mailboxes, homes, and offices. This marketing staple involves promotional pieces like brochures, postcards, catalogs, or even handwritten letters.

The primary purpose of such marketing is to reach a target audience and create a lasting impression quickly. A critical aspect of a successful campaign is the quality of the printed materials. This is where direct mail printing services come into play.

At CityPress, we ensure that your promotional items are visually pleasing and professionally made. Well-designed mail pieces can significantly enhance brand perception as they showcase a commitment to quality and attention to detail.

Email marketing

Email marketing involves sending promotional messages as electronic mail to a list of subscribers or potential customers. The purpose of such a marketing campaign is to engage recipients with the content quickly and efficiently.

You can personalize the emails based on the behavior of your target audience to increase engagement. Moreover, you can take advantage of its automation capabilities and reach a broad range of potential customers in a prompt manner.

Visibility and impact

A direct mail strategy has a tactile nature and quality that digital communication strategies often lack. This is a physical object that customers can hold, view, and feel, likely to get noticed compared to a pile of digital emails in the mailbox. 

Since the digital space is often crowded, direct mail often faces less competition. With fewer distractions in their mailbox, consumers can more easily notice and read the mail that your business has sent. 

In fact, many recipients perceive physical mail as more personal and reliable. According to some direct mail vs email statistics, up to 90% of the emails are opened compared to 20-30% of the emails. Physical mail also tends to linger longer in offices and homes, providing extended message exposure.

Reaching target audience 

Direct mail and email marketing offer targeted marketing opportunities but vary in reach and effectiveness. Direct mail directly targets an audience in a specific geographic area. In contrast, email marketing allows your business to access a global audience in a fraction of the time, overcoming geographic barriers. 

With direct mail marketing, you can target a specific audience based on geographic, demographic, and behavioral data. Conversely, email marketing is a strategy that segments audiences based on criteria such as audience behavior, demographics, and past interactions.

Reaching target audience
Source: / Photo Contributor: tsingha25

Engagement and response

In general, direct mail offers higher engagement metrics due to the physical presence of the promotional materials. However, email marketing enables real-time engagement tracking through open, click-through rates, and conversion metrics.

Given the emails are delivered almost instantly, they allow for quick engagement with the audience and a high response rate. They also enable quick deployment of campaigns, rapid adjustments, and optimization of marketing campaigns. 

Personalization, timing, and content relevance are critical factors that influence both email and direct email channels. One benefits from personalized touches like handwritten mail, and the other leverages dynamic content based on the recipient’s preferences. 

Cost considerations

Email marketing typically has a lower cost-per-contact in comparison to direct mail. The reason is that sending emails is relatively inexpensive compared to the print and postage costs associated with direct mail materials.

This makes email marketing an environmentally friendly and easily accessible marketing strategy for businesses of all sizes. The marketing costs for such marketing typically revolve around platform fees and design services.


Although it provides many advantages, direct mail also comes with certain challenges, such as higher costs, longer lead times, and difficulties in tracking ROI. Direct mail campaigns can be costly as they take longer to plan and execute. 

You need to design the materials, print them out, and then deliver them, compared to an email that you can send instantly. Moreover, the response time is typically slower as it takes time for the recipients to read and respond to the promotional materials. 

When it comes to email marketing, reduced visibility is a common issue. While emails are quick to send, they can end up in spam folders. Due to this, you must adhere to the best marketing practices to ensure high deliverability rates.

Another drawback of email marketing is oversaturation. The high volume of emails the consumers and workers receive can lead to lower engagement rates. As a result, you need compelling content that will stand out in a crowded recipient inbox.

Considerations to Take Into Account When Choosing Mailing Campaigns 

Business objectives

To make an educated choice, we recommend you align your marketing goals with the strengths of each marketing channel. Keep in mind that direct mail is ideal for building effective brand awareness and creating a memorable impact.

In comparison, email marketing excels at driving quick responses and ongoing engagement. Thus, your choice should be guided by the specific objectives of your campaign, such as lead generation, product promotion, and customer retention. 

Target audience

Understanding your target audience's needs, preferences, and behaviors is crucial when choosing a marketing campaign for your business. Direct mail may be more effective for reaching audiences that prefer traditional communication methods.

This type of marketing typically resonates with older demographics who appreciate tangible communication. In contrast, younger, tech-savvy audiences may respond better to such marketing.

Email Marketing
Source: / Photo Contributor: earth phakphum


Did you learn how to enhance customer engagement, reach the target audience, and drive more sales? Well, you may still be debating between both options - direct mail vs email marketing, each with unique advantages and challenges.

To sum up, direct mail is a tangible, high-visibility marketing option with potentially higher rates, albeit at a higher cost. In contrast, email marketing enables fast and cost-effective communication but faces challenges in terms of inbox competition.

With this in mind, you need to carefully evaluate your business goals, budget constraints, and audience preferences to choose the most effective channel. In some cases, integrating both can maximize overall marketing campaign success.


bottom of page